Thursday, December 4, 2008

web posters--change and climate

Today I'll blog about the remaining web posters, which focus on internal organizational communication, including organizational change and organizational climate. Cathyblog08 was interested in communicating organizational change, a slightly different take on organizational change than Hapa, who focused on changing organizational culture. What I found interesting was the research Cathyblog08 reported on that examined resistance to change. This research explores attitudinal and behavioral resistance to change and the role of communication in overcoming that resistance. I wonder if some of this resistance isn't a matter of employees recognizing that some change isn't good for the organization. For example, many faculty at SJSU resisted the change to Blackboard CE 6 and it turns out that it was a poor decision to adopt this particular learning management system.

Related to communicating organizational change is organizational climate, presented in Crives's web poster. Although the popularity of this topic has waned in recent years, the research still provides insight into organizational communication, especially between supervisors and subordinates. What I found most interesting is the need for research in light of Web 2.0 and new communication technologies. That is, the communication tools used to create organizational climate have greatly expanded, but as Crives points out, the research hasn't kept pace with these changes.

This is the final entry about the web posters. They reflected a range of interests in organizational communication, but also persistent themes, as with culture, technology, leadership, and change--all key issues in an age of globalization.

~ Professor Cyborg

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

web posters--leadership

In my entry today I'll blog about the web posters that focused on leadership and leadership-related issues. Kristle's web poster provides insight into classic and current views of organizational leadership. In reviewing the to do list for leaders, I was struck by how much we expect of them such as provide a vision, complete administrative tasks, manage employees, demonstrate empathy, and adapt to a changing environment. From my perspective, ideally leadership is shared, with multiple organization members stepping in to fulfill leadership functions that best suit individuals' particular knowledge bases and skill sets.

David's research provides a bridge between culture and leadership, exploring the effectiveness of various approaches to leadership in different cultures. This perspective is different from Hapa's, who was interested in leaders' roles in changing organizational culture. As David points out, the majority of leadership research has been conducted in the U.S. The research on leadership conducted outside the U.S. has revealed differences in what is expected of leaders, what it means to be a leader, and what is entailed in leadership. The paucity of research in cultural differences in organizational leadership suggests many avenues for future research.

BUS244 and Affan examined gender differences in verbal and nonverbal communication in the workplace. What I find most interesting about this research is the lack of significant differences between the two groups, especially when power is factored in. That is, differences often attributed to sex are better explained by status or how much power individuals are able to exercise in the organization. This web poster provides some insight into gender differences in leadership, which reside to a large extent on followers' expectations about how women and men should lead as well as leadership in general.

~ Professor Cyborg

Tuesday, December 2, 2008

web posters--technology

The web posters I'll discuss today center on organizing and new communication technologies. ZamoraDesign's research on information transparency in organizational communication examined the ways organizations use new communication technologies to make information easily accessible--or not. I like the notion of linking transparency with social responsibility. That is, part of being a good corporate citizen is making information available. Still, as several researchers point out, complete transparency is not only impossible but not advisable. Some information, such as employee records and trade secrets, have to remain inaccessible. And strategic ambiguity also suggests that clear and open communication is not always the best way to proceed. For example, sensitive negotiations between organizations may be best advanced with some equivocal communication. Mission statements are generally ambiguous to encourage agreement among all groups. What stood out in this web poster was the author's video discussion of future research, which personalized the poster.

I've done some reading on global virtual teams for a project I worked on with several colleagues. Such teams are becoming more common, especially as more organizations tap into personnel resources outside their traditional geographic boundaries. As PinkLady describes in her web poster, she's interested in this topic because she works in such a team. Some of the research in this area is rudimentary, but as the research moves away from basic comparisons of in person and online communication, organizational communication scholars will develop more sophisticated models of such teams as well as guidelines for best practices.

Anima's focus on virtual worlds and organizational communication fascinated me because of my experiences in online learning/teaching and my participation in groups and organizations that coordinate their efforts primarily online. When I attended the Association of Internet Researcher's conference last year, one of the founders from Linden Labs--the creators of Second Life--was the keynote speaker. The potential for collaborative work (as well as many other applications) in Second Life is there, but as Anima found in her research, far from fully realized. At this point, organizations seem more interested in using Second Life to develop a consumer base and not as interested in using Second Life was a work space. My dream is to have faculty meetings in Second Life. I wonder what avatars my colleagues would create.

~ Professor Cyborg

Monday, December 1, 2008

web posters--organizing and culture 2

In addition to the web posters I discussed yesterday, several others focused on organizational culture. Similar to Hapa, Violet's research focused on organizational culture and change. She identified the different aspects of culture that must be managed when attempting to change an organization's culture. Still, the research suggests that culture is not as easily managed as top executives might like to think.

Charlemagne focused on a specific group of people, front-line employees, and their role in organizational culture and the organization's performance. Classic research highlights the importance of front-line employees in presenting the public face of the organization and performing key aspects of the organization's culture. Current research emphasizes the importance of the organization's culture on front-line employee performance and the link to customer satisfaction. That is, front-line employees provide the conduit for organizational culture from the organization to those outside it.

Although CommBuzz doesn't directly address organizational culture, there's no doubt that culture plays a role in organizational identity. CommBuzz used the metaphor of a tree to present research on organizational identity grounded in social identity theory and structuration theory. Interestingly, CommBuzz found that research in this area focused primarily on lower-level employees and the degree to which they bought into the vision top management presents. What's neglected, however, is the contribution lower-level employees make to the development, maintenance, and change of organizational identity. So as with Charlemagne, CommBuzz is interested in how those outside of management participate in the creation of organizational life and sensemaking.

~ Professor Cyborg

Sunday, November 30, 2008

web posters--organizing and culture 1

This week we'll blog about the web posters. I first developed the idea for web posters based on student research when I had to design web posters for my classes. I started teaching online in 1999 and because online learning was so new, one of the staff members in eCampus (called the Distance Education program at the time) suggested web posters to get students interested in our online classes. The poster provided a useful way of summarizing information. So I adapted the idea for several of my classes. For the class this semester, students submitted 14 web posters. I'll briefly discuss two or three each day this week, grouping them together by themes. I'll start with some of the web posters that addressed organizing and culture.

Kartik focused on cross-cultural communication in organizations that operate in the U.S. and India. The two countries have become quite intertwined in many ways, but certainly in terms of organizations working in new communication technologies. And the recent terrorist attacks in India aimed at prominent Indian, U.S., and British executives underscores the close ties between U.S. and Indian organizations. Kartik's suggestions for future research demonstrate the gaps in the literature.

SS & Garota de Ipanema examined culture from an intercultural perspective. The authors provide several avenues for future research that identify areas where current research is sparse. One neglected area is the impact of local culture on global culture. This parallels the general cause-effect bias in culture research, which often assumes that a more dominant culture is impervious to the effects of a less-powerful culture. For example, there's much concern about the impact of Western culture on developing nations without considering the flow of culture in the other direction.

One of the most-discussed issues in the organizational culture literature is the ability of leaders and managers to change an organization's culture, the topic Hapa's web poster addresses. If all organization members participate in creating and maintaining organizational culture, is it possible for managers and leaders to bring about change? Although those in the upper echelons of organizational hierarchies may attempt changes in organizational cultures, research does suggest these attempts often fail. As Hapa points out, "The most striking finding of my research was the relatively low success rate of cultural change efforts."

~ Professor Cyborg

Friday, November 7, 2008

ethics of compassion

I didn't post yesterday because I wanted to report on the final reading group discussion that took place this afternoon. Faculty and students participated in the discussion of Dying to Get High: Marijuana as Medicine, with co-author Dr. Richard Webb leading the discussion. This conversation was different from the previous ones in that we had quite a few questions for Dr. Webb.

The book includes an interview with Dr. Webb in which he describes his experience as a caregiver for one of the WAMM members. The person became so ill that he lived with Dr. Webb for about 10 weeks, until the person died. In discussing this experience with us today, Dr. Webb told us that working with the people in WAMM and serving as a caregiver had led him to feel more compassion for others. That's a theme throughout the book, and speaks to the ethics of compassion briefly mentioned in Chapter 14 of the text. The authors note, "a number of Buddhist traditions embrace widening circles of compassion to include not only those close to us but also those distant and even our enemies" (p. 425). The members of WAMM seem to work hard to take this approach with those inside and outside the organization, designing a system of justice focused on meeting people's needs rather than assuring everyone contributes equal amounts to the organization.

Although this was the last department reading group discussion of the book, Dr. Webb will be presenting in the University Scholar Series in the spring. In addition, the department plans to sponsor a colloquium for next semester in which Dr. Webb discusses the book. In the meantime, read Dying to Get High. It's engaging and informative on multiple levels.

~ Professor Cyborg

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

power to define

Yesterday I met with the second reading group for the department's book choice this semester, Dying to Get High: Marijuana as Medicine, by Wendy Chapkis and Richard J. Webb. Dr. Webb joined the group, so we got first-hand insight into the story underlying the book as well as an update on the Wo/Men's Alliance for Medical Marijuana.

The book includes several interviews with organizational members and those involved in the medical marijuana movement. For one discussion question I asked, "In the interview with Dr. Arnold Leff [pro-medical marijuana Santa Cruz physician] he states, 'Advertising by big corporate pharma giants has helped to create a culture that encourages drug use' (p. 35) and uses the example of Ambien, a sleeping pill. What other examples can you think of to support his claim?" Discussants easily identified other examples of our "take a pill to fix it" culture. The discussion then turned to what constituted acceptable versus unacceptable drugs and the role of pharmaceutical companies in defining "good" and "bad" drugs.

In Dying to Get High, Chapkis and Webb note the power of large organizations such as the pharmaceuticals, the AMA, and government agencies to define terms and dominate the discussion of medical marijuana. As Cheney et al. discuss in Chapter 9, "the ability to define terms is an extremely important part of the debate" (p. 258). Chapkis and Webb identify the ways in which powerful groups set the agenda for the discussion of medicine and drugs, limited the availability of information of the medicinal uses of marijuana, and silenced viewpoints about the plant.

~ Professor Cyborg

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

context and organizing

Yesterday afternoon six students and I discussed Chapkis and Webb's book, Dying to Get High, Marijuana as Medicine. I had developed 25 questions to guide the conversation, which lasted two hours. One question focused on the context in which the Wo/Men's Alliance for Medical Marijuana developed: "In Chapter 2, the authors discuss the set and the setting and argue that Santa Cruz provided the petri dish in which WAMM could grow. What about Santa Cruz made WAMM possible? Could WAMM exist anywhere else?"

I asked this question because organizational communication researchers often ignore the cultural and political environment in which organizations function. In Chapter 11, Cheney et al. discuss the socio-historical context of organizational change, tracing the history change in terms of what was happening at the time. For example, "the movements that began in the 1970s (organizational culture, quality circles, and Toyotism) all reflect a shift in the change-constancy dialectic toward a greater valuing of change" (p. 318). WAMM represented a change in addressing the needs of the those with chronic pain or illness, especially those who were poor and lacked health insurance. The organization grew out of an intersection of a particular political climate (progressive) and particular group of people (activists). WAMM enjoyed strong support from the community, including the major and city council and several health care groups. In addition, the group worked with the sheriff, who was supportive of California's medical marijuana initiative.

The reading group discussants agreed that an organization such as WAMM might be possible in another place with similar cultural and political leanings. At the time WAMM was organized, the climate in Santa Cruz related to the issue of medical marijuana was supportive of the change side of the change-constancy dialectic. However, the group also acknowledged the importance of the organization's founders and additional members who kept the organization going, especially in times of adversity.

~ Professor Cyborg

Monday, November 3, 2008

analyzing organizational artifacts

In Chapter 15 Cheney et al. discuss collecting and analyzing organizational communication data. The authors identify four primary ways to gather data: artifacts, surveys, interviews, and observations. Chapkis and Webb's research reported in Dying to Get High relies primarily on artifacts, interviews and observations.

The authors devote two chapters to artifacts. One chapter provides extensive details on the methods the Wo/Men's Alliance for Medical Marijuana used to process the medical marijuana. In "Mother's Milk and the Muffin Man" readers learn about alternatives to smoking marijuana, such as ingesting it in soy milk and chocolate muffins. While some members are able to tolerate smoking marijuana, many cannot but still need the medical benefits of the plant. More importantly, the chapter describes the tremendous amount of work several members of the collective go through to transform the marijuana into appropriate delivery systems. The members use every part of the plant, developing tinctures, mari-caps, and a liniment. The production of these artifacts reflects the complex nature of the plant and the issues associated with it.

The chapter "Love Grows Here" provides the most insight into the organization's culture and its essence. In this chapter, the authors describe WAMM's garden, situated in Santa Cruz county with stunning views of the Pacific Ocean. The space is defined as a healing garden in which "relationships are formed between garden volunteers and the plants under their care" (p. 161). Members form strong bonds as they work in the garden. Growing marijuana well is labor intensive and requires a cooperative effort among members--a cooperation that isn't always achieved. The garden provides a symbolic representation of the organization. When the DEA raided the garden in 2002, the event devastated the garden as well as the organization. Including a chapter that focuses on the garden provides key insights into how members felt during and after the raid.

This afternoon I'm leading the first discussion of the book. I'll report on that tomorrow.

~ Professor Cyborg

Sunday, November 2, 2008

alternative organizations

As I've mentioned in previous entries, much of my research in organizational communication as focused on small groups and teams. Chapter 8 discusses democracy and participation in alternative organizations (noncorporate entities, which are the vast majority of organizations to which we belong). The authors discuss the problems these organizations often encounter, such as lack of time, emotion, inequality, self-maintenance, autonomy, and goal persistence. I just finished reading Dying to Get High: Marijuana as Medicine, by Wendy Chapkis and Richard J. Webb. Rick is a lecturer in my department. He earned his M.A. in communication studies at SJSU and was in BUS/COMM 244 the first time I taught it. He then went on to earn his Ph.D. from the U of Texas at Austin in organizational communication.

The book is at once a narrative about a social movement, medical marijuana, and a case study of an organization, the Wo/Men's Alliance for Medical Marijuana (WAMM), located in Santa Cruz. Structured on the notion that everyone should take what they need and give what they can, the organization attempts to function as a collective, holding weekly meetings in which the group addresses policy, structural, and process issues. But as an almost entirely volunteer organization, the group encounters the challenges associated with any alternative organization. For example, some members actively participate, tending the garden, making cannabis products, planning events. Others just show up for the meetings, don't say anything, and leave with their medicine. Some people are simply too ill and too poor to contribute much. Still, those who enjoy better health and wealth feel conflicted, understanding on one level that everyone can't contribute equally, but resenting those who don't participate.

I'll be writing more about the book this week because it's the department's reading group book for the semester. This week I'm leading three discussions about the book and participating in a fourth (Dr. Webb will lead that one). The story is fascinating for me as an organizational communication scholar as well as someone who's lived in Santa Cruz since 1994.

~ Professor Cyborg

Thursday, October 23, 2008

organizational change

This week SJSU launched its advising hub on the university website. It’s certainly a welcomed addition; advising has been a weak point at SJSU since long before I arrived on campus. As the university’s requirements have become more complex, advising becomes more essential. Yet with more students and fewer faculty, having the time for effective advising is challenging. So the advising hub should help guide students toward graduation and reduce some of the need for faculty advising.

At the beginning of Chapter 11 the authors of the text provide a summary of what makes organizational change efforts successful. A key component is acceptance by organization stakeholders in fidelity (a match between the intended use and how its used) and uniformity (all targeted users adopt it). I wonder the degree to which the advising hub will work. I hope it works well, but in my first glance through it, all the text and links are overwhelming. And then there’s this at the bottom of the first page: "WEBSITE DISCLAIMER: This SJSU advising site is new this fall. We have not verfied [sic] that all the information on every link is accurate, and our lists, links and materials are not exhaustive." Scary!

My eyes start to glaze over when faced with a lot of text; I figure that’s true for my students as well. And the advising hub website has a lot of text with pages that go for several screens. In contrast, for a project I’m doing in the spring, I’m working with students to develop podcasts (that will include transcripts) on things students know now about SJSU that they wished they had known when they started. The podcasts will work as an advising tool, but in formats students will find more accessible: they can read the transcript, watch the video, or just listen to the audio.

For organizational change to work, it must be planned and must involve those who will be implementing and living with the change. The advising hub planners may have done that; it's not clear from the site. But the format doesn't seem very user-friendly, so students may not use it as much as the planners might have hoped.

~ Professor Cyborg

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

management gurus

Box 11.5 in your text asks the question, What role do management gurus play in promoting organizational change? The author, Brad Jackson, “viewed the gurus as part of a whole management fashion industry” (p. 325).

Change in organizations necessarily involves both organization managers and leaders. While this "Voices from the Field" could have been included in Chapter 7, the focus here is more specifically on organizational change. This example provides a nice bridge between the two chapters.

In my experience at SJSU, major organizational changes have stemmed from those in the upper levels seeking to fill out their résumés, rather than following a reasoned, planned approach to change. SJSU is near the end of another overhaul based on a new vision. By my count this is the fourth "new" vision for SJSU since I arrived in 1990. This latest reinventing of SJSU, called Vision 2010, is based on an education guru book, Student Success in College: Creating Conditions That Matter, that identifies 20 highly successful universities and colleges. At least one review suggests universities and colleges can apply different aspects of the authors' findings to each institution's unique situation. However, another review suggests that the authors ignored the featured institutions' shortcomings--which may be instructive as well. As one step toward applying the suggestions in the book, SJSU has formed an Achieving Greater Expectations Institute designed to "bring faculty, staff, students, and administrators together to focus on enhancing student learning and developing a sense of belonging to SJSU to foster student success." I wonder how many students know about it.


Gurus can bring in new ideas and fresh ways of thinking. However, they can also apply a one-size-fits-nobody approach to organizational change that hurts more than helps the organization. Ultimately, if the management guru does a poor job assessing the organization's current state, needs, culture, climate, etc., then change likely will not go well. So the guru has to work closely with organization members at all levels to implement planned change effectively.

~ Professor Cyborg

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

image restoration discourse

Because I’m interested in the images organizations attempt to create, maintain, change, and manage, I found the examples of image restoration discourse on p. 306 in Chapter 10 intriguing. Although I’m sure SJSU has had to apply some of these strategies in the past, today I decided to examine a university that had been put on probation by the NCAA.

Nicholls State University recently completed its probation for ethics violations. The University president blogged about the incident last February. (Interestingly, the comments function on the blog is not available.) The president used several strategies to restore the university’s image. First, he used defeasibility, indicating that had he known about the actions of others, he would have done something immediately. He also used the corrective action strategy, stating the new compliance officer “was directed to be more active in preventing violations on the front end rather than policing the Athletics Department for violations after the fact.” Near the end of the statement the university president says, “while the violations and the resulting penalties were painful and embarrassing, Nicholls State University has handled them with maturity and determination,” using the bolstering strategy by emphasizing the university’s positive traits.

Large corporations often come to mind when studying how organizations restore their images, yet all organizations have to address this issue. For colleges and universities, image is especially important in attracting students. A university may have plenty of wonderful programs, but if its image is poor due to inept responses to crisis situations, then students will go elsewhere.

~ Professor Cyborg

Monday, October 20, 2008

issue control tactics

The issue control tactics Cheney et al. list in Box 10.6 (p. 287) ring true for me, although I am curious about the research on which the list is based. I searched for a footnote in that section of the chapter, but I couldn't find one.

Although these are applied to the organizational context, they seem even more relevant to political communication. The debates are over for the current presidential campaign, but the rhetorical jousting for votes will continue up until election day. Directing attention away from an issue is a common tactic. Both nominees used this strategy to respond to questions they didn't want to answer or to press an issue they thought was more important. The clearest example of limiting access to information is McCain's refusal to disclose his medical records (there's concern over his treatment for melanoma). Some have argued that Obama has not been forthright in his disclosure about associations with Bill Ayers.

Defining what type of information is considered relevant was a tactic frequently used in the debates, with each arguing the other's evidence was irrelevant, wrong, or misleading and then presenting his own evidence. The creating fear of raising an issue tactic has been applied to race and age. Creating criteria for decisions or priorities that frame the decision has been used to tote the advantages of each candidate's tax and health plans. Defining the problem, decision, or conflict in definitive terms has been applied to the economic crisis, the Iraq war, and health care (to name a few issues).

Cheney et al. point out that these tactics allow communicators to covertly exercise power and avoid or suppress conflict. What's frustrating for voters when politicians use these tactics is the lack of real discussion and debate over complex issues.

~ Professor Cyborg

Sunday, October 19, 2008

labor and communication

Box 10.11, authored by Dana Cloud, associate professor at the U of Texas, Austin, focuses on labor issues in the new economy, arguing that the plight of most workers really hasn't changed. Currently, Professor Cloud is organizing a boycott of the Manchester Hyatt Hotel in San Diego, the site of the National Communication Association convention in November. The owner of the hotel contributed to the Yes on Prop 8 campaign. In addition, Unite Here claims it's been trying to unionize the hotel for some time.

The boycott has involved individuals not staying at the convention hotel and some groups moving their events off site. Several persons with disabilities have noted that they must stay at the hotel to participate in the convention and getting to any events no longer at the hotel isn't possible. There's been quite a bit of discussion about the issue on NCA's listserv.

Rather than boycotting the hotel (NCA reserved the hotel five years ago; the Manchester Hyatt will get its money even if some people choose to host their events elsewhere), my department decided to protest in the hotel. We chose a slogan and one of our graduate students (who was a graphics designer in a former life) developed a design for a t-shirt and button. If members of the department want to support this form of protest, they can order their t-shirt or button and wear it at the convention. The faculty decided the best way to address the issue is to engage people in discussion rather than leave the scene.

~ Professor Cyborg

Thursday, October 16, 2008

resistance in organizations

In their discussion of power in Chapter 9, Cheney et al. note that "resistance implies something being resisted--usually a stronger force, resource, person, or institution" (p. 266). As the faculty in residence for the Accessible Technology Initiative in the College of Social Sciences I've observed instructors' resistance to making all their course materials accessible.

The initiative originated from the very top of the organization--the the CSU's Board of Trustees. The mandate is simple in its phrasing but has far-reaching consequences:
It is the policy of the CSU to make information technology resources and services accessible to all CSU students, faculty, staff and the general public regardless of disability.

This means that students will not need to self-identify as having a disability and therefore needing access to specific course material (although students still will need to register with the Disability Resource Center for services such as test accommodations). All new courses must be have course materials accessible by the end of the semester. All courses must be accessible by fall 2012.

My role is to help faculty in the college make all their instructional materials accessible to students. These materials include syllabi, handouts, digital slides (e.g., powerpoint), video (closed-captioned), and webpages. For documents, accessible means it's in a digital and editable format (so, for example, a screen reader can read the document or the student could enlarge the text), text equivalent information is included for images, hierarchical identifiers are included (such as headings), no extra spaces or lines, no text boxes, no relying on color for emphasis, no blinking visuals, and links to websites are described (rather than saying something like click here).

Most of the faculty I've spoken with do want to make their course materials accessible, although some are concerned about sharing all their class notes and digital slides because they view these materials as intellectual property. Others, however, are quite resistant for two reasons. First, they view ATI as another unfunded mandate from the CSU. I agree that converting all instructional materials into accessible formats is time consuming. But once you know how to design accessible materials, it's pretty basic. Second, they object to the increasing pressure for standardization in course materials, such as formats for syllabi, viewing these pressures as an infringement on their academic freedom. From my perspective, however, designing my syllabus in whatever manner I want isn't academic freedom; what I choose to cover in my class is where academic freedom comes in. If SJSU faculty truly want the campus to be a center of inclusive excellence, we must design our classes for all students.

~ Professor Cyborg

Wednesday, October 15, 2008

language, disability, and power

How power is evident in talk interests me. As the authors point out in Chapter 9, defining terms is one way to exercise power. My research in communication and disability has focused on disability as a contested term. In a chapter for Communication Yearbook 27, I identified six metaphors of disability, discussing the ways each metaphor empowered/oppressed persons with disabilities.

Disability as a medical problem suggests persons with disabilities must be repaired. This metaphor disempowers persons with disabilities, although more recent conceptualizations may provide useful tools for empowerment. For example, empowerment medicine suggests that individuals can act on and change their physical, political, societal, and economic environments. Disability as cognition focuses on the influence of attitudes toward disability or individual differences in personality traits that influence disabled-nondisabled interaction, moving away from objective notions of disability to subjective ones. This metaphor provides some avenues for empowerment in recognizing attitudes of prejudice and stereotyping that contribute to the oppression of persons with disabilities. However, the metaphor oppresses persons with disabilities in that those without disabilities are defined as the norm; persons with disabilities are Other or abnormal.


Disability in culture examines the influence of culture on what constitutes disability, highlighting the ways that cultural definitions oppress and disempower persons with disabilities. To the extent that persons with disabilities participate in communication concerning disability, disabled persons influence the language (and images) used in empowering ways. To the extent that persons with disabilities remain excluded from those discussions and defined as not fully human, then persons with disabilities will face continued oppression. Disability as culture views persons with disability forming distinct cultures/co-cultures, underscoring the empowering potential of disability as a cultural identity. Further, recognizing disabled-nondisabled interactions as intercultural communication underscores the ways in which persons without disabilities stereotype, discriminate against, and disempower persons with disabilities. However, oppression may manifest itself in the subordination and rejection of disability culture and co-culture.

Disability as politics recognizes the importance of empowering relationships in public and private interactions. The transformation of disability identity from dependent, stigmatized, and abnormal to independent, accepted, and normal constitutes the metaphor's foundation. Recognizing disability as a political and social label provides a critique of the dominant "ableist" perspective on what defines humanness and personhood. Thus, disability as politics strikes at the core of disability oppression and brings with it the power to construct one's identity.

Finally, disability as community incorporates several perspectives to provide a more complex view of disability and communication. This metaphor of disability, particularly with its focus on new communication technologies, most clearly demonstrates empowerment strategies that provide an avenue for persons with disabilities to fully participate in the social construction of their life experiences. For example, the metaphor removes the static notion of a uniform disability culture and proposes multiple co-cultures found among diverse group members who share some things in common and yet in other ways are distinctly different.

If you're interested in reading the article, the full citation is:
Coopman, S. J. (2003). Communicating disability: Metaphors of oppression, metaphors of empowerment. In P. J. Kalbfleisch (Ed.), Communication Yearbook 27 (pp. 337-394). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

~ Professor Cyborg

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

paradoxes and democracy

For several years I was involved in a professional organization governed by a board of directors that conducted nearly all its business online. The organization was quite innovative, launching the first online journal in the discipline committed to publishing work across the field, not just research about the internet, digital media, or computer-mediated communication. I was a member of the organization briefly, then elected to the board of directors. Two years later I was elected president, and then the board selected me to edit the journal--the second editor in the journal's existence.

The last part of Chapter 8 discusses paradoxes in democratic organizations that address four aspects of organizing: structure, agency, identity, and power. Reading this section reminded me of my time with the professional organization and the struggles members faced. Although the organization encountered paradoxes in all four areas, paradoxes of power were the most difficult for the organization members to manage productively. In academe, we like to think of ourselves as egalitarian, but in reality, multiple hierarchies exist within the academy. The organization was challenged both with resolving issues of control and leadership within the board as well as the larger hierarchical norms in the discipline and academe. For example, senior scholars who were well-known in the field generally carried more sway in board member discussions. In addition, founding members of the organization had greater influence as well. These control and leadership issues often conflicted with the organization's hierarchy. As you can imagine, some meetings became quite heated.

Although I enjoyed (most of) my time with the organization--especially editing the journal--managing those paradoxes became time consuming, tiring, and distracting. As communication scholars, we should have done a better job addresses the paradoxes of democratic organizing.

~ Professor Cyborg

Monday, October 13, 2008

democracy and organizational communication

The About Us page of the Department of Communication Studies website includes this:
The B.A. and M.A. programs focus on four primary areas or cornerstones: democracy, diversity, technology, and globalization.
  • Democracy - affirms the balance of individual freedom and socio-political consensus shaped through dialogue, argument, and persuasion between individuals and groups.
  • Diversity - explores the variety and complexity of communication efforts to shape beliefs, values, and perceptions in different communities and cultures.
  • Technology - interrogates the implications of human communication in a mediated world.
  • Globalization - recognizes the interconnectedness, integration, fragmentation, and conflict within human societies and cultures in global contexts.
All faculty (at least tenure-track) claim they cover these concepts in their classes, but sometimes I wonder if we really do. And in spite of the lofty definitions, I wonder how the terms are put into practice. For example, how democratic is the department? Who is included in departmental decisions and who is not?

In the small group communication text my spouse and I are writing, we discuss five models of democracy: procedural, competitive, participatory, deliberative, and dialogic. So just in that sense, democracy is more complex than the department's definition. In addition, the emphasis on consensus ignores the necessity of conflict and the reality of power in any democratic system, issues Deetz addresses in his work. But as Cheney et al. point out, "Democracy, thus, is a 'god term'--an unquestioned good--for many societies" (p. 215).


Certainly in the U.S., democracy plays a central role in the nation's collective identity. And it certainly plays such a role in the department's identity. Because of democracy's status as a god term, however, we fail to interrogate what we mean by democracy for our students and in practice for department decisions. For example, major departmental policy decisions seldom involve lecturers and never involve students. Who gets to participate in the department's democracy? The U.S., founded on democratic principles, has not always allowed everyone to participate. And restrictions on voting exist today. Because democracy is an unquestioned good, closely examining democratic processes in organizations is all that more important.

~ Professor Cyborg

Sunday, October 12, 2008

democracy and health care teams

As I've already mentioned, I've conducted research in hospice interdisciplinary teams. My early work focused on person-centered communication in supportive and persuasive contexts. Later, I examined team processes, including democratic decision making.

Chapter 8 discusses two views of democracy and participation in organizations. One heralds the value of greater employee participation in decision making. The other notes the dark side of so-called democracy, with employees taking on more responsibilities without any compensation. My work in hospice wasn't concerned with the degree to which democracy was "real," but rather with team members' perceptions of democratic processes.

I found that in practice the hospice teams were less democratic than they're typically portrayed in the hospice and health care tea literature. I also found that involvement in decision making was the most important component of the democratic process in terms of how team members evaluated several team and individual outcomes: productiveness and cohesiveness, overall team communication, satisfaction with the team, and desire to stay with the team. In addition, team productiveness was a mediation variable between involvement with the team and job satisfaction.

For me, the most important outcome of this research was that it highlighted the need to train hospice team members in how to work together. Often organization members are thrown into situations and expected to work as a team. But without the training, people simply don't know what to do. While hospice interdisciplinary teams generally serve as exemplars for effective health care teams, members could still benefit from explicit training in teamwork.

If you're interested in reading the article, the citation is:
Coopman, S. (2001). Democracy, performance and outcomes in interdisciplinary health care teams. Journal of Business Communication, 38, 261-284.

~ Professor Cyborg