Thursday, September 4, 2008

practical ethics

The authors of your text argue that ethical communication serves five ethical functions in organizations: coordination, community, inspiration, social control, and emulation. This practical approach underscores how ethical communication is more than just something that should be done for itself. Ethical organizational communication benefits all the organization's stakeholders.

Many organizations adopt a code of ethics. The National Communication Association published its Credo for Communication Ethics in 1999. The Academy of Management's general ethical principles focus on responsibility, integrity, and respect for people's rights and dignity. The National Speakers Association has a code of professional ethics that provides guidelines for how members should conduct themselves.

SJSU has incorporated an ethical stance in its goals for Vision 2010 with "Responsible citizenship and an understanding of ethical choices inherent in human development" for graduate and undergraduate students. In addition, the university has adopted Ten Principles of Academic Integrity for faculty and a Student Conduct Code for students. Five years ago Student Affairs started an Academic Integrity week to encourage dialogue about ethical issues on campus. In the past, the event has included guest speakers, workers, and discussions.

~ Professor Cyborg

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

celebrating diversity

Near the end of Chapter 13 the authors of your text refer to Edward Said's argument that organizations should celebrate diversity rather than try to management. This is the approach SJSU is taking in its strategic planning and the creation of a new position Assistant to the President and Director of Institutional Planning and Inclusive Excellence, currently fulfilled by Dr. Rona Halualani, professor of communication studies. Last year Dr. Halualani implemented a two series of focus group discussions, one with faculty and staff and the other with students, to encourage the campus community reflect on diversity issues at SJSU. The outcomes of these discussions are now part of the university's strategic planning process. Celebrating diversity is also part of Vision 2010, another piece of the strategic planning process. Part of Vision 2010 involved revisiting SJSU's mission and goals. One goal in particular suggests a celebration of diversity:
  • Multi-cultural and global perspectives gained through intellectual and social exchange with people of diverse economic and ethnic backgrounds.

Still, in the faculty and staff focus group in which I participated, attendees voiced skepticism of the university's ability to commit the resources necessary to support diversity at all levels of the institution. For example, the university's Bridge Program, which helps first-year students adjust to college life has been scaled back in recent years.

~ Professor Cyborg

Monday, September 1, 2008

organizing and social imagination

The forces of globalization and new communication technologies have increased the expansiveness of organization members' social imaginations--conversations about past, current, and future identities. I've observed this locally in my department, especially during the past year. At the end of the spring 2007 semester, four faculty left the university and two moved into administrative positions. Several of former group had been obstructionists, making it difficult to have any real dialogue in meetings. But with those individuals gone and the introduction of new communication tools (such as department wikis), the faculty were able to have useful conversations about the department's present identity and the ways that identity might change. The results were dramatic, evident in the department's new website, facebook group, tagline (Listen • Speak • Engage), tagline image (above), and the re-envisioned major and graduate program.

Many diverse scapes influenced our discussions, including those related to individual cultural identities, professional allegiances, university culture, economic realities, and the like. At the same time, faculty were reflecting on these scapes and seizing the opportunity to define themselves, the department, and the programs. The new identity has already started to emerge, but will come into sharp focus in Fall 2009 with the new undergraduate and graduate programs.

~ Professor Cyborg

Sunday, August 31, 2008

organizing and globalization

Globalization is in the title of the text for this class. More than just a buzz word, globalization impacts how organizations today function and organizations impact the process of globalization.

Several years ago the faculty in my department identified four cornerstones for the program: democracy, diversity, globalization, and technology. We defined globalization as "the interconnectedness, integration, fragmentation, and conflict within human societies and cultures in global contexts." I'm more interested in the pragmatics of globalization and the extent to which ideas, organizations, money, people, and the like move freely (or not) around the globe.

The authors of your text define globalization in the context of organizational communication as "the process through which the global economy becomes increasingly interconnected, through which global and domestic organizations merge, and through which communication technologies blur traditional spatial and temporal boundaries" (p. 382). There are many plusses to globalization, such as an increased ability for organization members to collaborate without regard to physical proximity. On the minus side, organizations have been able to outsource labor to cheaper locations.

As the authors of your text point out in Chapter 13, treaties, laws, and agreements related to globalization privilege property (and organizations) over individuals, especially labor. Globalization is here to stay, but we must consider the impact it has on local economies and the ability of workers to move as easily across borders as goods and products do.

~ Professor Cyborg

Thursday, August 28, 2008

theory and organizing

You've probably heard people say, "That's just a theory." Yet as the authors of your text point out, theories are practical, taking "us beyond particulars toward universals" (p. 11). A good theory helps explain why things are the way they are. In organizational communication, good theories help explain how and why people organize.

Students often want to know which theory is the best. There is no one best theory, but some theories are better than others in their explanatory power, elegance, application, utility, relevance, and creativity. One criticism of many communication theories, including those in organizational communication, is their Western bias. That is, most theories of communication are grounded in Western culture, especially the dominant U.S. culture. This is why the authors of the text include "relevant to different cultures and historical periods" as a criterion for a good organizational communication theory.

You'll likely find it easy to critique early theories of organization, yet it's important to consider the historical context in which those theories--and any theory--are embedded. For example, human relations and human resources arose in response to criticism of classical management theories. Yet classical management theories provided the first systematic view of organizations, so their importance should not be neglected.

If you've taken courses in business or industrial psychology many of the theories discussed in the text will be familiar. As you read the chapters, however, consider the differences between a business or psychology approach to organization and a communication approach. The research questions organizational communication scholars posed (examples listed in Chapter 1) should give you some insights into those differences.

~ Professor Cyborg

Sunday, August 24, 2008

metaphors and organizing

Chapter 1 in the Cheney et al. book introduces the notion of metaphor in examining organizational communication, providing a list of possible metaphors on page 5. I find the notion of metaphors intriguing because they tend to go unnoticed, yet impact how you think and act.

In 1980 Lakoff and Johnson published Metaphors We Live By. The authors argued that metaphors embedded in the language communicators use shape how they interpret and create messages--that is, how individuals respond to their worlds. SJSU lecturer Dr. Janice E. Patten provides a useful summary of the book's key points on her website, The Literary Link.

About 10 years ago one of communication studies faculty tried to impose a metaphor on the department--a village. While that action seems innocuous, metaphors influence how you think about organizations (and other things as Lakoff and Johnson argue, such as love, war, and ogres--Shrek says to Donkey, "Ogres are like onions") and, in turn, the process of organizing. For example, if you think of organizations as machines, then you just replace parts (people) when they're broken. It doesn't matter who the person is, just as long as you have someone for each part of the machine. In contrast, if you think of organizations as organisms, then you become concerned with the organization's health, and the health of the people who make up the organization.

In the "village" case, faculty members not only thought that the metaphor was inappropriate, but that having someone dictate the metaphor certainly didn't reflect a cooperative sort of village. (Maybe something closer to a fiefdom.) As another example, one faculty member I know at a university in the midwest unmentioned referred to his department
as a "pit of vipers." That strong metaphor speaks volumes about faculty relationships.

At a conference I heard someone describe the internet as more of a city than an unknown space. I like that metaphor for organization as well. "City" suggests the complexity of organization, with parts that you know well (your neighborhood), parts you somewhat know, and parts you really don't know at all. City also suggests diversity in people, activities, ways of transiting, and ways of communicating. There's structure, but not necessarily rationale or logical reasons for that structure. Cities are in continual flux, embedded in (and often in power struggles with) larger social structures such as counties, regions, states, and countries. Different cities have different rhythms--Santa Cruz sort of eases into the day, San Francisco is awake all night, and Seattle settles in for an early evening to start at dawn the next day. Finally, cities have their charms, but also their dark sides.

Although metaphors are useful in understanding organizing, organizations, and organizational communication, these linguistic devices always foreground some things while hiding others.

~ Professor Cyborg

Friday, August 22, 2008

end of summer

Summer officially ended yesterday with the first faculty duty day. I spent the morning beta testing the new website builder for SJSU that will allow faculty to (fairly) easily develop webpages and make course information accessible to students. The pages will listed at people.sjsu.edu, a much friendlier URL than the previous one. And the URLs for the faculty sites will be more logical as well. My beta site is up for the next 2 weeks. I'm not doing too much with it because I'll lose all the work when beta testing is over. The system is far better than Spartan web wizard, which is completely nonintuitive.

At noon yesterday the new SJSU president, Jon Whitmore, spoke. He's started his own blog, although there's no way to comment on it. It's really just a webpage that SJSU's PR office calls a blog. But maybe this does indicate his desire to move SJSU into the 21st century.

The last part of the day was the department faculty meeting. With all the lecturers and TAs, we fill the COMM Lab. Once that group leaves, tho, there are just over a handful of tenure-track faculty. Administrators like a faculty with a high percentage of lecturers, but because only a few have service duties, it puts a tremendous burden on the tenure-track faculty. We simply don't have the number of faculty we need to complete all the tasks that need to get done.

Today is our second duty day. The college meeting was this morning. Not many faculty there; everyone's getting ready for the start of classes next week. With SJSU facing record enrollments, Monday will be hectic. I'll be home in Santa Cruz, teaching online.

~ Professor Cyborg