Tuesday, September 9, 2008

online communication and equal participation

On page 363 the Cheney et al. state, "In addition to its ability to stimulate a strong task-orientation in work groups, computer-mediated communication seems to facilitate more equal participation among organizational members." I've found this to be the case with online classes and my colleagues who teach online agree. In person classes privilege students who better speakers, are more outgoing, and more comfortable in a dynamic communication environment where there's often little time to reflect on what others have said. Some of my online students have emailed saying that the online class was the first one they spoke out in.

I've observed this in faculty discussions as well. When we move part of our work online, as with editing documents on a wiki, one or two people are less able to dominate the conversation and we tend to make better decisions--because everyone has an equal opportunity to participate (whether or not they take that opportunity is up to the individual). With in person meetings, there's only so much time, and it can be difficult to divide up the talk time in any equitable way. Asynchronous online communication also gives faculty time to think about what others have said before posting their comments or making changes in a document. In developing the department's new major and graduate program (to be implemented in Fall 2009) faculty found the wiki indispensable. We met in person as well, but much of the hard work took place online.

Online communication doesn't necessarily lead to all group members (or all students in a class) participating equally. But in my experience asynchronous online communication levels the playing field so everyone has the opportunity to participate without worrying about a few people dominating the conversation. Although individuals can send many lengthy emails or write many long posts on a discussion board, other participants can delete or skip those messages--the lengthy messages don't take away from others' ability to participate. With in person meetings, if a few people use more than their share of talk time, there simply isn't enough time for others to have their say.

~ Professor Cyborg

Monday, September 8, 2008

tech failures in organizations

Box 12.8 in your text discusses a research project Ted Zorn started on communication technology adoption and implementation in organizations. He began the project in early 2001, but after a year, found that the projects were either abandoned or implemented poorly. The authors of your text provide three reasons for the tech failures: (1) the systems led to increased rather than decreased workload, (2) the systems were too complex, and (3) insufficient training and development for users.

As someone who has taught online for nearly 10 years, I've observed these kind of mistakes in technology adoption at my university as well as other schools. For example, using Blackboard CE6 is far more work than using WebCT 4.0. One problem is that it can only be opened in one web browser window at a time. So as an instructor if all my files are in blackboard, I can look at only one page at a time, unless I open a window in a different browser. The system is much more complex to use and completely nonintuitive. And training has been spotty.

Another major reason technology adoptions fail is the lack of employee participation in the decision making process. This is true for any major changes in organizations. Without members' participation in all aspects of the change process, getting buy in during the implementation stage is challenging. In addition, important information is overlooked.

Involving faculty in deciding which learning management system to use may have led to a better decision at the university. As it is now, Blackboard is not compliant with accessibility laws, and if that remains the case, the university will have to go to a new system in two years--another failure in technology adoption. Consulting with a wider range of campus stakeholders might have resulted in choosing a different LMS that fit all users' needs.

~ Professor Cyborg

Sunday, September 7, 2008

technology and surveillance

In Chapter 12 of the text the authors note early on, "Some writers warn that communication technologies imply increased management surveillance and control" (p. 346). There's no doubt this is happening in U.S. and international workplaces.

Several years ago two of my colleagues and I were on a hiking trip. We were talking about organizational communication (no surprise; we went to grad school together and all studied in that area). I had been teaching online for a few years and had recently taught the undergraduate course in organizational communication. I'd been amazed by how much students talked about organizational surveillance and the degree to which they were watched and monitored during their work day.

So the three of us decided to work on a project where we examined how organization members talk about surveillance. Rather than focusing on the types of surveillance, we wanted to know what people had to say about being surveilled. We developed a survey. Our students conducted interviews. We presented our findings in several venues, the most-recent one an article in Management Communication Quarterly. We thought study participants would report about all the ways they tried to subvert and work around surveillance systems. We were so wrong! Most organization members accepted the surveillance, buying into the reasons given when they joined the organization or when the surveillance was installed
("it's for your safety," "it increases productivity").

Especially in turbulent economic times organization members are hesitant to challenge the status quo and and their bosses. During times when jobs are easy to come by, organization members are more likely to resist control mechanisms such as surveillance systems. Still, consider the impact of upper management's poor decisions and unethical behavior (think of Enron, the savings and loan scandals, the current mortgage crisis). Where should the surveillance cameras be placed? In the organization's cubicles or the board room?

~ Professor Cyborg

Friday, September 5, 2008

the ethics of speechwriting

The Mercury News today included an op-ed piece on the ethics of politicians using speechwriters. The author, who in the 1970s wrote term papers for a company that sold them to students, argues, "selling term papers to students to use as their own is still illegal, but selling speeches to politicians to use as their own remains a legitimate enterprise." What does this have to do with organizational communication? The issue may seem only related to political communication, but organizing is at the core of politics--the two major political parties often are referred to as "machines" because they're highly bureaucratic organizations.

Speechwriting brings up the notion of accountability Cheney et al. raise at several points in Chapter 14, particularly in the section on ethics as an issue for organizations. But there seems to be a double standard. For example, the author of the op-ed piece, David McGrath, points out that the president of Jacksonville State U was chastised for having someone else write at least three of his weekly newspaper column with crediting the writer. Yet politicians commonly use speechwriters without attribution and that's accepted.

For an interesting take on plagiarism, including an index on plagiarists, visit War on Plagiarism, a site developed by John Lekso, English Professor at Saginaw Valley State University.

~ Professor Cyborg

Thursday, September 4, 2008

practical ethics

The authors of your text argue that ethical communication serves five ethical functions in organizations: coordination, community, inspiration, social control, and emulation. This practical approach underscores how ethical communication is more than just something that should be done for itself. Ethical organizational communication benefits all the organization's stakeholders.

Many organizations adopt a code of ethics. The National Communication Association published its Credo for Communication Ethics in 1999. The Academy of Management's general ethical principles focus on responsibility, integrity, and respect for people's rights and dignity. The National Speakers Association has a code of professional ethics that provides guidelines for how members should conduct themselves.

SJSU has incorporated an ethical stance in its goals for Vision 2010 with "Responsible citizenship and an understanding of ethical choices inherent in human development" for graduate and undergraduate students. In addition, the university has adopted Ten Principles of Academic Integrity for faculty and a Student Conduct Code for students. Five years ago Student Affairs started an Academic Integrity week to encourage dialogue about ethical issues on campus. In the past, the event has included guest speakers, workers, and discussions.

~ Professor Cyborg

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

celebrating diversity

Near the end of Chapter 13 the authors of your text refer to Edward Said's argument that organizations should celebrate diversity rather than try to management. This is the approach SJSU is taking in its strategic planning and the creation of a new position Assistant to the President and Director of Institutional Planning and Inclusive Excellence, currently fulfilled by Dr. Rona Halualani, professor of communication studies. Last year Dr. Halualani implemented a two series of focus group discussions, one with faculty and staff and the other with students, to encourage the campus community reflect on diversity issues at SJSU. The outcomes of these discussions are now part of the university's strategic planning process. Celebrating diversity is also part of Vision 2010, another piece of the strategic planning process. Part of Vision 2010 involved revisiting SJSU's mission and goals. One goal in particular suggests a celebration of diversity:
  • Multi-cultural and global perspectives gained through intellectual and social exchange with people of diverse economic and ethnic backgrounds.

Still, in the faculty and staff focus group in which I participated, attendees voiced skepticism of the university's ability to commit the resources necessary to support diversity at all levels of the institution. For example, the university's Bridge Program, which helps first-year students adjust to college life has been scaled back in recent years.

~ Professor Cyborg

Monday, September 1, 2008

organizing and social imagination

The forces of globalization and new communication technologies have increased the expansiveness of organization members' social imaginations--conversations about past, current, and future identities. I've observed this locally in my department, especially during the past year. At the end of the spring 2007 semester, four faculty left the university and two moved into administrative positions. Several of former group had been obstructionists, making it difficult to have any real dialogue in meetings. But with those individuals gone and the introduction of new communication tools (such as department wikis), the faculty were able to have useful conversations about the department's present identity and the ways that identity might change. The results were dramatic, evident in the department's new website, facebook group, tagline (Listen • Speak • Engage), tagline image (above), and the re-envisioned major and graduate program.

Many diverse scapes influenced our discussions, including those related to individual cultural identities, professional allegiances, university culture, economic realities, and the like. At the same time, faculty were reflecting on these scapes and seizing the opportunity to define themselves, the department, and the programs. The new identity has already started to emerge, but will come into sharp focus in Fall 2009 with the new undergraduate and graduate programs.

~ Professor Cyborg