I really enjoy reading the Voices from the Field boxes, so you may notice that I blog about them often. In Box 15.2, the authors feature Jill McMillan discussing native organizational communication research in which scholars study the organizations in which they're embedded. Several years ago one of my master's students, Kay Meidlinger, studies the stories of the organization where she worked, the office of her local Catholic church. Kay had attended Catholic church all her life and at the time of her study had worked as a member of the parish staff for some time. She collected stories during the regular staff lunches. Because of her extensive knowledge of her own parish and the larger organization in which the parish functioned, she could provide insight into the stories not possible from an outsider's viewpoint. After she completed her thesis, we collaborated on two articles. The first, published in the American Communication Journal focused on the types of interpersonal stories the participants told. In the second, published in Management Communication Quarterly we took a critical view in examining how the stories supported (or didn't support) the status quo. Having both an insider's and outsider's view provided greater depth of analysis as we discussed our interpretations of the data.
~ Professor Cyborg
In Box 15.1 the authors of the text report on Connie Bullis's work in environmental communication. Bullis argues, "our greatest challenge maybe to change our personal choices while also looking to innovative organizational approaches" in addressing environmental issues. So cycling to the grocery store instead of driving, not buying products with excess packaging, and raking up the leaves in the yard rather than using a leaf blower.
Going green at the organization can prove challenging. When I was acting chair this past spring and summer, I decided the department would no longer buy water in 16 or 20 ounce containers. We already had a water cooler in the copy room (old pipes in HGH make the tap water suspect), so I ordered one for the COMM Lab as well (old pipes an issue in the Clark Building as well). Then I set about trying to find a "green" reusable water bottle that the department would purchase and sell at cost to students, faculty, and staff (with the department's new tagline stamped on it). First I thought we could use bottles made out of recycled plastics. But there were concerns about chemicals leaching into the water. Then I checked out the popular naglene bottles, but similar issues with those. I finally settled on a stainless steel bottle. More expensive, but no leaching issues. Now I'm trying to find out if it's made in the U.S. (lower carbon footprint).
Of greatest concern in Bullis's comments is the symbolism associated with going green. It's become the "in thing" to do, so companies use language associated with sound environmental practices but may not actually be implementing such practices at all. "Green" is used because it sells, not because the organization is concerned about the Earth's future. I found when searching for water bottles that "eco-friendly" and similar terms were associated with products that didn't seem to be good for the environment at all.
~ Professor Cyborg
In Chapter 15, Cheney et al. suggest that "the metaphor of text draws our attention to how much of an organization is written, spoken, and, thus, constructed by its members through the linguistic and other symbolic resources available to them" (p. 438). Other communication scholars have argued that organizing is communicating. Still, the text metaphor presents a specific view of communication. The authors go on to note that the metaphor illuminates issues of authority and power and takes the mystery out of organizational structures and processes.
Although the text metaphor is intriguing, it is also static and linear, as is the notion of "reading" an organization. Text also suggests a notion of permanency, which considering the latest failings of financial firms in the last few weeks, may not provide a useful representation of the changes and flux organizations experience. Particularly in the current turbulent environment, other metaphors may better serve our understanding of organizations and organizing.
The recent near-collapse of very large and very old U.S. financial institutions suggests that as communication scholars we must go beyond a myopic focus on communication and consider the real implications of accounting in organizations. One of my colleagues at Central Michigan University suggested that all organizational communication students take at least one class in accounting so they could read a balance sheet. There's no doubt that communication played an integral part in the rise and fall of the subprime mortgage fad, but when the money simply isn't there, all the talk in the world won't bring it back.
~ Professor Cyborg
The emphasis on the rational actor that persists today in organizational studies and practice also impacts the norms that have developed associated with the expression of emotion. Rational decision making suggests that emotions play no role in how decisions are made in organizations, yet organization members often are driven by how they feel about others and the organization.
Another aspect of emotions in organization is what emotions are okay to express and what must be hidden--the emotional labor the authors of the text discuss in Chapter 3. While the organizational norms associated with the expression of emotion are culturally-bound, the growth of transnational corporations has blunted some of the impact of local cultural practices on the organizations in which they're embedded. Norms may also vary with the type of organization. For example, in the hospices I studied, expressing joy, happiness, sadness, and grief were quite accepted. Providing comfort to others in difficult times was common. Crying, especially in response to a patient's death, was considered normal behavior. Expressing anger was not as accepted, however.
The study of emotions in organizations is fairly recent and still hasn't received much attention. This likely stems from the dominance of the machine metaphor in our understanding of organization. Even later metaphors such as organizations and organisms, organizations as brains, and organizations as political systems ignore the role of emotion in everyday organizational life.
I first read about the garbage can model of decision making in a graduate course at the U of Kentucky. As Cheney et al. describe this approach, decision making in organizations involves "collections of: solutions looking for problems; issues and feelings seeking to be aired; and decision makers looking for decisions to make" (p. 60).
Rather than decisions occurring in a logical, linear fashion, decisions are much more haphazard and driven by all sorts of forces that aren't apparent. Once a decision is made, then a narrative is developed to explain it. For example, the recent decisions to bail out AIG insurance, Freddie Mac, and Fanny Mae have far-reaching implications. Rumors abounded for weeks and months that the federal government would rescue these institutions. The garbage can model suggests that the decisions were made and then those involved worked to develop a rationale for those decisions, what the authors of the text (and others) call "retrospective sense making" (p. 60). In this way, the decisions were legitimized after the fact rather than following a systematic process to reach a conclusion.
In Images of Organization Gareth Morgan discusses eight metaphors for organization: machine, organism, brain, culture, political system, psychic prison, flux and transformation, and domination. Relying on Morgan's conceptualization of organization as brain, the authors of your text discuss the brain metaphor in box 3.4. One strength of this metaphor is it promotes the idea of the learning organization, so it goes beyond the organism metaphor that portrays organizations as adapting to their environments. The brain metaphor suggests that organizations enact their environments and can be proactive and reactive.Still, the brain metaphor suggests a rational approach to organizing and decision making. Yet as you've probably found, organizational decisions are often all but rational. Hidden agendas, personal biases, political maneuverings, and emotions are all involved in how organization members make decisions. This was certainly the case with a professional organization I belonged to for several years. Organization members made several poor decisions in spite of information that would have suggested a different course of action. Personalities became more important than reasoned discussion. The organization--already small--lost several key members due to the conflict.
Although the brain metaphor is useful, Morgan notes "there is a danger of overlooking important conflicts that can arise between learning and self-organizing, on the one hand, and the realities of power and control, on the other hand. . . . Moreover, the process of learning requires a degree of openness and self-criticism that is foreign to traditional modes of management" (p. 117). Images of Organization is a fascinating book and a classic in the field. I've used it in the past for the BUS/COMM 244 seminar. But the second edition is over 10 years old and I wanted a text that was published more recently. Still, Morgan's book is an essential read for all students of organizational communication.
Systems theory is grounded in the organism metaphor for organizations (although the application of organizations as systems can implicate the machine metaphor as well). As the authors of the text note in Chapter 2, systems theory encourages communication scholars to examine the larger environment in which organizations are embedded. Although this theory has its drawbacks, such as the emphasis on unity and harmony, it provides a way to take a more macro view of organizational life.
The notion of equifinality underscores one of the problems with highly bureaucratic structures. Equifinality suggests that there are multiple ways to reach the same endpoint and the starting point doesn't determine the endpoint. When applied at a micro level to teaching, this means all instructors teaching a particular course can have the same learning objectives but have different ways to achieve them. The trend toward assessment and standardization of course curriculum runs counter to equifinality. Although this trend has been well entrenched in K-12 for some time, it's just beginning to occur at the college level as well. For example, in the upper-division writing class in my department, all instructors use the same syllabus with the same assignments. I find this trend discouraging.