On Tuesday I blogged about the department and how faculty worked together to create the department's tagline and tagline image. I emphasized the importance of that process in giving participants a stake in identity creation. What I hadn't thought about, however, was those who were left out of the process--students, staff, and part-time lecturers. Although the process was more inclusive than that of the university's, all unit members did not participate. I should note, though, that we did ask students for their ideas about the department's tagline, emailing all majors for their suggestions. Two students responded. I posted their ideas to the faculty wiki and we used those ideas as a basis for our discussion.
Similarly, for the COMM Club, only those who attended the two meetings in which the discussion of the logo took place were able to comment on the logo. All COMM majors were invited to the meetings (unlike the faculty meetings where students, staff, and part-time lecturers were not invited), so you could make the argument that the club's members attempted to be inclusive. But in person meetings privilege students who have the time to attend and don't have other commitments during the meeting. To provide greater inclusivity, the Club could have put the draft logos online and invited comments.
In spite of these criticisms, though, the club and department did seek greater stakeholder department than the university did when designing its new logo and identity standards. As Cheney et al. point out, "Although 'participation' and 'diversity' have become management buzzwords . . . , few managers today seem willing to tolerate unfettered communication about the organization's identity by employees and external stakeholders" (p. 129). When former SJSU President Robert Caret imposed the SJSU tagline "Silicon Valley's Metropolitan University" and changed the SJSU logo from the Tower to the bricks, faculty were angered, viewing the change as arrogant because so few were involved in the decision. Cheney et al. observe, "Corporate identity management is typically the domain of a relatively small clique of decision makers speaking on behalf of the rest of the organization" (p. 129). This was true of the Caret decision and of the more recent decision to change the SJSU logo and no longer allow units to develop their own logos. The new identity standards make clear the university's priorities: "The primary brand of San José State University is San José State University. All the colleges, departments, etc, make SJSU the great institution that we are, but the university as a whole is the most important aspect of our identity." Public Affairs has created "lockups" or logos for all university units. Units have no need to create their own identities; PA has already done that for them.
~ Professor Cyborg
In Chapter 4, the authors of the text discuss Martin's three perspectives on organizational culture: integration, differentiation, and fragmentation. Although Martin's work is a bit dated (1992), her work is cited widely and provides useful insight into this perspective on organizational culture. The most important contribution from Martin's work is the identification of the fragmentation approach.An integration approach to culture stresses harmony and similarities; the differentiation approach focuses on separation and conflict; and the fragmentation approach turns our attention to multiplicity and flux. Thus, from a fragmentation perspective, there is no one interpretation of meaning and meanings change from moment to moment. The world does not have the order and predictability found in the other two perspectives. The fragmentation approach to organizational culture is clearly rooted in postmodernism.Martin defines culture from a fragmentation perspective as, "a web of individuals, sporadically and loosely connected by their changing positions on a variety of issues. Their involvement, their subcultural identities, and their individual self-definitions fluctuate, depending on which issues are activated at a given moment" (p. 153). Martin uses the jungle metaphor to stress the unknown and unknowable nature of culture from the fragmentation perspective.In applying the fragmentation approach to organizational culture, co-cultures (Martin uses the term subcultures, but co-cultures is a more accurate term) are no longer clearly defined. Organization members move in and out of co-cultures, so insiders and outsiders are less differentiated and boundaries are porous and mutable. Ambiguity is central to organizational life and must be an integral aspect of any study of organizational culture.Recognizing the centrality of ambiguity in organizations moves organizational scholars away from oppositional or dichotomous thinking and toward more complex views of organizational culture. So the fragmentation perspective explores multiple meanings of what is present as well as what is absent. For example, in analyzing stories, researchers from the fragmentation perspective seek multiple story interpretations and also consider what stories are not told or which organization members are not part of the story. The fragmentation perspective recognizes ambiguities in symbols, ideology, and action. These ambiguities and multiple interpretations do not necessarily come together as a coherent whole. Organizational cultures are characterized by inconsistency, paradox, and contradiction.
~ Professor Cyborg
Chapter 5 in the text focuses on organizational identity. The authors defined organizational identification this way, "A person identifies with an organization when he or she seeks to select alternatives with the interests of the organization--as best they can be determined--uppermost in mind" (p. 114).As an employee in an organization, I've never been overly enthusiastic about identifying with the organization. Developing a sense of community is important, but I like having "me" at least somewhat separate from the organizations in which I'm embedded. Still, in a place like SJSU with commuter students, faculty, and staff, creating community and organizational identity can prove challenging. Recently the department embarked on an initiative to examine its curriculum. As part of interrogating the program, faculty also developed a tagline (Listen • Speak • Engage), a tagline image (aka, our logo), and revamped the department website. Although the outcome was important because we now have tangible representation of who were are as a department, what brought us together more, and encouraged identification with the organization, was the process. We worked as a group to come up with the tagline. For our tagline image, one of our graduate students (a graphic designer in a previous life) took us through 3 rounds of ideas until we identified an image we all liked. For the department website, we integrated that image along with our renewed commitment to making program information more accessible. And students have noticed this. Several have told me Listen • Speak • Engage is "everywhere" and they say it helps them articulate what it means to major in communication studies. I have no interest in assimilation, but I do want students, faculty, and staff to feel like they have a stake in the department.~ Professor Cyborg
Much of the work in organizational culture has taken an ethnographic approach, studying the culture of a particular organization. As Cheney et al. note, "ethnographers . . . study how social realities are constructed locally" (p. 81). The research involves observation or participant observation and detailed descriptions of organization members' everyday sensemaking.
Over 10 years ago, John Haas, Beverly Davenport Sypher, and I observed that although there are distinctions across organizations in cultural practices and other indicators, there are commonalities. We'd been involved in collecting data in several organizations on communication climate and information flow. What interested us was that in every organization, members wanted more information, no matter how much information they already received. With one exception, across all channels and sources, organization members wanted more communication. The only source they didn't want more information from was the grapevine--they didn't want more rumors. Yet, the grapevine was rated as both healthy and accurate in every organization. In the Journal of Business Communication article we published on our research, we identified this desire for more communication as a metamyth "whose basic tenet is that 'more communication is better'" (p. 196).
What also sets apart this research from more traditional organizational culture studies is the use of quantitative methods. Examining survey data from five different organizations allowed us to observe the metamyth trend that ethnographic data would not have revealed.
~ Professor Cyborg
Box 4.2 in Chapter 4 discusses the work of one of my colleagues at SJSU, Dr. Federico Varona. The article cited, Conceptualization and Management of Communication Satisfaction and Organization Commitment in Three Guatemalan Organizations, was published in the American Communication Journal when I was editor. This research is interested in the influence of the larger culture on the organizations studied. The two most important contributions of Dr. Varona's are understanding communication satisfaction as a more nuanced construct and recognizing the multidimensionality of organizational commitment.
But what I like best about the study is what Dr. Varona's cultural and professional background brought to the research. Summarizing his experiences living and working in Guatemala he says in a footnote: "During the fourteen years that I lived in Guatemala, I had the opportunity to interact with people of all social classes Indigenous and Ladinos, poor and rich, and professionals and workers from a great variety of organizations and institutions. This experiential knowledge along with my expertise as a scholar allowed me to get to know Guatemalan culture and Guatemalan organizations." As with Kay Meidlinger's extensive knowledge of the Catholic church and her research on parish staff members' stories, Dr. Varona's background provided a level of analysis and insight those unfamiliar with Guatemalan culture could not provide.
~ Professor Cyborg
In the section near the end of the chapter on overall research orientations, Cheney et al. observe: "Most analyses of communication content emphasize what is said or what is present in the 'text' . . . . In some cases, however, there might be important elements that are notable for their absence" (p. 465).
Several years ago one of my master's students, Shannon Waltrip-Sequiera, did her thesis research on how parents and teachers socially construct the notions of progression and regression in children with autism. She focused on the communication of two teachers and one parent about the parent's child with autism. As part of the program designed by the child's school, the teachers and parent wrote in a notebook that went to school and home with the child each day. The main focus of the notebook was addressing the child's needs, although topics varied. Shannon analyzed several years of the notebook's content and conducted in-depth interviews with the teachers and parent.
One interesting finding was the near absence of the parent's voice. The teachers dominated the communication in the notebook; the parent generally followed their lead in defining the child's progression and regression. In this case, as Cheney et al. suggest, the absence of the parent's communication was noteworthy, particularly when it was replaced by a grandparent's contributions to the notebook.
~ Professor Cyborg
In Chapter 15, Cheney et al. observe, "To understand organizational communication, it's often important not to focus on a single message but rather to look at a broad pattern" (p. 440). This quote reminded me of my dissertation work. My committee included an interpersonal communication scholar, a qualitative methods media studies scholar, a quantitative health communication scholar, and two sociologists, one a critical theorist and the other a specialist in complex organizations. Quite a mix of perspectives for my project on person-centered communication in hospice interdisciplinary health care teams.
For my dissertation, I used observation, focus groups, individual interviews, and a questionnaire to gather data. My primary focus was on the messages team members exchanged when comforting and persuading each other. By examining a large body of messages, I was able to tease out patterns of person-centered communication. Still, that provided a fairly micro view of organizational communication. The sociologists on my committee encouraged me to consider the broader environment in which the teams functioned, including the larger organizational structures and the realities of the U.S. health care system. For example, the critical theorist pointed out that these hospices, which were not-for-profit, functioned in a for-profit world, interfacing with hospitals and insurance companies. As I blogged about previously, interacting with these highly bureaucratic organizations influenced the hospices' internal structures.
When Cheney et al. emphasize the need to go beyond a single message and examine patterns, they're also suggesting that organizational communication researchers place their work within the larger contexts in which such communication takes place.
~ Professor Cyborg