The About Us page of the Department of Communication Studies website includes this:The B.A. and M.A. programs focus on four primary areas or cornerstones: democracy, diversity, technology, and globalization.
- Democracy - affirms the balance of individual freedom and socio-political consensus shaped through dialogue, argument, and persuasion between individuals and groups.
- Diversity - explores the variety and complexity of communication efforts to shape beliefs, values, and perceptions in different communities and cultures.
- Technology - interrogates the implications of human communication in a mediated world.
- Globalization - recognizes the interconnectedness, integration, fragmentation, and conflict within human societies and cultures in global contexts.
All faculty (at least tenure-track) claim they cover these concepts in their classes, but sometimes I wonder if we really do. And in spite of the lofty definitions, I wonder how the terms are put into practice. For example, how democratic is the department? Who is included in departmental decisions and who is not?
In the small group communication text my spouse and I are writing, we discuss five models of democracy: procedural, competitive, participatory, deliberative, and dialogic. So just in that sense, democracy is more complex than the department's definition. In addition, the emphasis on consensus ignores the necessity of conflict and the reality of power in any democratic system, issues Deetz addresses in his work. But as Cheney et al. point out, "Democracy, thus, is a 'god term'--an unquestioned good--for many societies" (p. 215). Certainly in the U.S., democracy plays a central role in the nation's collective identity. And it certainly plays such a role in the department's identity. Because of democracy's status as a god term, however, we fail to interrogate what we mean by democracy for our students and in practice for department decisions. For example, major departmental policy decisions seldom involve lecturers and never involve students. Who gets to participate in the department's democracy? The U.S., founded on democratic principles, has not always allowed everyone to participate. And restrictions on voting exist today. Because democracy is an unquestioned good, closely examining democratic processes in organizations is all that more important.
~ Professor Cyborg
As I've already mentioned, I've conducted research in hospice interdisciplinary teams. My early work focused on person-centered communication in supportive and persuasive contexts. Later, I examined team processes, including democratic decision making.
Chapter 8 discusses two views of democracy and participation in organizations. One heralds the value of greater employee participation in decision making. The other notes the dark side of so-called democracy, with employees taking on more responsibilities without any compensation. My work in hospice wasn't concerned with the degree to which democracy was "real," but rather with team members' perceptions of democratic processes.
I found that in practice the hospice teams were less democratic than they're typically portrayed in the hospice and health care tea literature. I also found that involvement in decision making was the most important component of the democratic process in terms of how team members evaluated several team and individual outcomes: productiveness and cohesiveness, overall team communication, satisfaction with the team, and desire to stay with the team. In addition, team productiveness was a mediation variable between involvement with the team and job satisfaction.
For me, the most important outcome of this research was that it highlighted the need to train hospice team members in how to work together. Often organization members are thrown into situations and expected to work as a team. But without the training, people simply don't know what to do. While hospice interdisciplinary teams generally serve as exemplars for effective health care teams, members could still benefit from explicit training in teamwork.
If you're interested in reading the article, the citation is:
Coopman, S. (2001). Democracy, performance and outcomes in interdisciplinary health care teams. Journal of Business Communication, 38, 261-284.
~ Professor Cyborg
The cover of the October 13, 2008, issue of TIME includes the headline, "The Leadership Deficit," as part of a series of story on the current economic crisis. The article focuses on the lack of credibility and trust members of Congress and the White House have with Americans. As the report, Michael Grunwald, put it, "Americans are always skeptical of politicians, but he financial meltdown has made it clear they no longer believe much of anything Washington's current batch of newscycle-obsessed, responsibility-dodging wold criers have to say" (p. 43). Harsh words. But it does seem that the vision those in Washington want the rest of the country to accept (e.g., "trust me, this will work") isn't selling very well.
Cheney et al.'s discussion of vision in Chapter 7 provides some insight into the cynical response Washington's recent bailouts have received. The authors of the text note that much attention is paid to those who formulate vision and missions statements and not enough attention is paid to those who are supposed to buy into those lofty words. Cheney et al. have four suggestions: personalize vision statements to local contexts, refer to those statements when introducing new program, express enthusiasm for the overall vision, and develop a personal theory or organizing mechanism for how the vision can be practically applied. From my perspective, vision is what's lacking in this entire debacle. There doesn't seem to be any overarching principle for the actions taken in Washington. And we do look to our leaders to take the steps necessary to develop and explain the economic vision for the country. In spite of the leadership alternatives discussed at the end of the chapter, we elect politicians because we expect them to lead. Right now, I agree with Grunwald that leadership is lacking.
~ Professor Cyborg
I've always liked Karl Weick's work. His writing is engaging. He using intriguing metaphors, such as linking organizing with jazz. His 1969 book, The Social Psychology of Organizing, had a tremendous impact on organizational studies. In a recent article with Kathleen M. Sutcliffe and David Obstfeld, Weick elaborates on the notion of sensemaking in organizations. The authors argue, "Sensemaking involves the ongoing retrospective development of plausible images that rationalize what people are doing" (p. 409). They go on to discuss sensemaking as organizing flux, starting with noticing and bracketing, about labeling, retrospective, about presumption, social and systemic, about action, and organizing through communication. Interesting that a social psychologist in a school of business argues organizing is about communicating. If you'd like to read the article, here's the citation:
Weick, K. E., Sutcliffe, K. M., & Obstfeld, D. (2005). Organizing and the process of sensemaking. Organization Science, 16, 409-421.
So it's not surprising that Weick argues against traditional approaches to leadership. In Chapter 7 of the text the authors note that Weick reverses the "walk the talk" buzz phrase. Because Weick takes the stance that organization members engage in retrospective sensemaking--acting and then thinking--talking the walk may be more productive. In this way, leaders match their words to their actions, which may give them greater flexibility. Weick's concern is that if leaders have to match actions to words, then the words will be more cautious, less innovative, and less compelling.
~ Professor Cyborg
The notion of relational dialectics, developed as an interpersonal communication theory, resonates with me because it helps explain the tensions individuals encounter in their relationships. I find it much more appealing than cognitive dissonance theory, which suggests we seek to reduce dissonance and that reducing that dissonance is possible. Relational dialectics recognizes the inherent tensions in relationships--we learn to manage them, but they're always there. So although it's an interpersonal theory, it's useful for the authors of the text to include it in Chapter 6.The authors list six dialectics, connection-autonomy, openness-closedness, novelty-predictability, equality-inequality, instrumentality-affection, and impartiality-favoritism, applying them to relationships in organizations.A few years ago I presented a paper at the Association of Internet Researchers in which I examined dialectics about disability identity in blogs written about disability by persons with disabilities. I was especially interested in blogs because historically identity is grounded in the body, but the internet severs that relationship, allowing persons with disabilities freedom from being constrained by physicality in online identity construction.In conducting a close reading of five exemplar blogs, I found four dialectics: individual-societal (disability as a private and public experience), difference-unity (unique identity and commonality with others), permanence-temporary (stability/change in identity and the temporal nature of disabilities), and dependence-independence (control and relying on others). I found that individual-societal was the most prevalent--the one the five bloggers grappled with the most. Dependence-independence was also crucial, although it didn't receive as much attention. The latter two weren't emphasized as much.
Although this research isn't directly about organizational communication, it provides insight into identity construction for persons with disabilities.
~ Professor Cyborg
Yesterday's entry came from my professorial persona. Today's is from my department events coordinator one. Chapter 6 emphasizes the importance of relationships and networking in the workplace. About 2 weeks ago the department hosted COMM Career Day, which I organized. Over 50 students attended. The panel included a representative from the Career Center and five communication studies alumni. Every speaker talked about the importance of networking to get a job and to change jobs within an organization. Speakers mentioned using internships, interviews (informational and employment), professional organizations, and even social contacts for networking. As the authors of your text observe, "Much of the research on relationships at work has focused on their instrumental role in career success--the networks that people form and the role of those networks in advancing careers" (p. 141). The authors then point out that organization members form relationships for other reasons as well. Still, the workplace context will always influence the nature of those relationships. For example, I've maintained friendships with many of the people with whom I went to graduate school at the U of Kentucky. We have personal connections, such as visiting each other outside the work context and talking about topics other than work. But we keep those professional ties as well, working together on projects, serving on panels, and meeting up at conventions. For example, I found out about the text I use for the class from Ted Zorn, one of the authors, because we both went to UK and we're part of a network of UK grads.
~ Professor Cyborg
On page 149 of the text Cheney et al. briefly mention Barbara O'Keefe's work in message design logics. O’Keefe argues that individuals differ in their basic beliefs about the function of communication, or message design logics. These individual differences are reflected in the ways communicators construct and interpret messages. For expressives, the purpose of communication is to express one's thoughts and feelings. Conventionals view communication as a game with participants following shared conversational rules. Finally, rhetoricals see the self and situations as socially constructed and negotiated in talk. For rhetoricals, communication is no longer what one does within a context (conventional), but rather, communication is the means through which interactants create socially shared contexts and negotiate definitions of self and other.
Message design logic follows a general developmental progression (O'Keefe & Lambert, 1995). The three logics are hierarchically ordered, with the expressive design logic the first individuals acquire, conventional the second, and rhetorical the third. Some individuals do not develop a message design logic past expressive; others acquire the conventional system, but do not progress to the rhetorical system; and others progress through the expressive and conventional logics and acquire the rhetorical view. However, when the next system is acquired, the previous one is not discarded but is subsumed within the more advanced level. As message producers move up the hierarchy from expressive to conventional to rhetorical, they have more options in how and to what ends they use language. Therefore, they are better able to identify interpersonal goals (theirs and others') and adapt their messages to achieve those goals.
In a lecture O'Keefe presented at the U of Kentucky when I was a graduate student, she argued that the logics generally were evident only in problematic situations. That is, under most circumstances, we all appear to be conventionals, following the rules of conversation. Particularly when conversational goals are simple, clear, and straight-forward, message design logics are not readily apparent. However, when we are trying to handle multiple, often competing goals, then how we think communication functions influences our ability to achieve those goals. In such situations, expressives will generally say whatever they're thinking, conventionals will be concerned with following the rules, and rhetoricals will try to find a way to negotiate the rules and definitions of self to manage the multiple, competing goals.
~ Professor Cyborg